Where in LI was this? I'm in NY and I'm interested in trying to get CB Gray Tree Frogs as an alternative to taking them from my backyard, but I'm trying to avoid the 1-day shipping cost if possible, and was thinking maybe I could find one at an reptile show. I've never been to a reptile show or even heard of any in NY personally, so I don't know how common they are.

Edit: I just actually took a look at that website you posted, and that almost answers all my questions already. There's even one in White Plains coming up, 30 minutes from my hometown. Now if only I wasn't four hours north.