European Toad

[Kurt]

Neither would I.















Just kidding. LOL

[coltiger]

I grew up in Scotland and remember those toads. We always called them the European toad as it is found across most of Europe, there is also a sub species from Japan Bufo japonicus I think that is the right name. I couldnt imagine this toad being illegal to keep as it is abundant. Maybe a bylaw or something kinda like one we got here that forbids you too keep Salamanders and turtles.

[Kerry1968]

I've sent an email query to the Joint Nature Conservation Commitee as they are the advisors to the government and were involved with the setting up of the Wildlife and Conservation Act that British amphibians are protected by.

Here is the email I sent....


I am aware that it is illegal to sell British wild caught amphibians.

I have seen for sale this week a Common toad (Bufo bufo) in a local reptile shop, they have it labelled as an European toad.

I suppose there is no way of proving that this animal is wild caught or captive bred, so it may be hard to do anything about it, but I wondered if legally they are allowed to sell a British toad, if that, in fact, is what it is?


I await their response.

[Kurt]

Bufo japonicus is a completely different species from Bufo bufo.

[coltiger]

Thanks for correcting me on Bufo japonicus I do remember reading about them, perhaps it is Bufo bufo's closest relative. As for the laws on keeping the toad in Britain I wouldnt know if it is legal or not. It would be interesting to know for sure even though I live in Canada now.

[Kurt]

Thanks for correcting me on Bufo japonicus I do remember reading about them, perhaps it is Bufo bufo's closest relative

Well, they are still in the same genus, even after Frost made his revisions to the genus Bufo. Those two are of a small handfull he did not rename.
Most of the toads we know are now in different genera according to his revisions. Bufo marinus is now Chanus marina, Bufo americanus is now Anaxyrus americanus, Bufo alvarius is now Ollotis alvaria, Bufo guttatus is now Rhaebo gutttus, Bufo viridis is now Pseudepidalea viridis, and so on. Bufo bufo and Bufo japonica remain the same.

[Kerry1968]

The reply from them.......


Thank you for your email. You are right, the Common Toad Bufo bufo (also known as the European Toad) is protected under Schedule 5 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, in respect of section 9 (5).

This section forbids its (a) sale or (b) advertisement for sale.

According to section 9 (6) of the act, “In any proceedings for an offence under subsection (1), (2) or 5 (a), the animal in question shall be presumed to have been a wild animal unless the contrary is shown.”

Thus the responsibility lies with the reptile shop to show that it is not a wild animal for it to be sold legally.

I would advise you to get in touch with your relevant country conservation agency (Natural England, Countryside Council for Wales, Scottish Natural Heritage, or Northern Ireland Environment Agency, depending on your location) to follow this matter up.

Best regards,

Anna Robinson

Biodiversity Information Officer



So now I need to contact Natural England!

This is the next email....


Hello, I emailed JNCC regarding this matter and they reccommended I get in touch with you.

I have seen a Common toad for sale in my local reptile shop, they have it labelled as an 'European toad', but as this is the same species I understand this is illegal.

What is the next step? Is there anything that can be done?

I look forward to hearing back from you




And so the tale continues!