To be honest, I haven't given a proper name yet for the time being because its hard to determine an American Toad's sex at a young age. So I've been referring to him/her as "Toad", for now. Simplistic yet very direct
That's cool! Lydia knows her name for sure, so, maybe a unisex name? Also, doubt they'll care what sex humans associate with their name. I'm definitely interested in your story with your toad, it would be neat if you started a thread to tell it as it continues!