So I've had my three dudes for just over three weeks, and it's been a learning experience. My tank is 65-land, 35-water, and I regret that so much now. They spend so much time in the water. All of their time. For awhile, Pickle, my smallest dude, stuck to the land portions, or hid, but he, too, is now spending all his time in the water. If I had a tank that was built to hold water, I'd change it in a heartbeat.
Now, I sold my parents on getting these guys on the fact that they'll eat nightcrawlers, which they do. Sorta. Mine sometimes, often spitting out a mouthful after striking and going off the sulk for a bit. Recently (this past week) they've just decided to stop eating the worms altogether. Which. Why? (Weather getting colder, I made some asthetic changes to the tank, they just really hate that calcium+worm slime flavor...)
So I bought some mealworms, which, while not especially great for these guys, can be used as a treat, and I thought that might entice them to start eating, or, at least, get some calcium or vitamins into them. No-go. I don't think they're moving enough to get the toads' attentions.
I decided today that I was getting crickets, come Mell or her daughter. So I did, because my parents got that the toads needed to eat, and I'd given it my best effort. And the result was pretty immediate. Streak gunned for two of them, and Pickle has eaten two as well. I'm just waiting for Sash to catch on, but, she's always been the pudgiest, so, I'm not too concerned.
Long story short: yeah, they'll begrudgingly eat nightcrawlers. But, good gracious, crickets are the way to go. Seriously.
The only problem with crickets is a few of them crawled between the plastic tub and the substrate and basically around the false-bottom area, but, I can live with that. I clean that area out once a week anyway.
And now, some pictures of my dudes.(Took 'em from my cell phone, so, quality's not great.)
This is Sash, named for the diagonal line of dots across her back.
This is Streak, named because of the long streaks of black down their back.
And this is Pickle, because he's very lumpy and reminded me instantly of a baby dill pickle.