I got a phonecall from my local petstore that with their shipment of feeder fish, they received two tadpoles. I went up to have a look and couldn't just leave them. However, though I am leaning towards American Bullfrogs, I cannot be sure as they look different than Poe.
They are a lot smaller than Poe (the little one is only about half the size); they have very distinct, well defined black dots on their tails; they have darker bodies, and, most importantly, both already have back legs.
A quick ID would be greatly appreciated. If they are American Bullfrogs, I will most likely NOT keep them as I don't think I can afford to feed three adult bullfrogs plus the rest of my zoo. If they aren't, I may be willing to give them a permanent home. Thanks everyone.