Please help ID my tadpoles/frog

[science7]

Can anyone help identify these frogs/tadpoles? I live in Virginia in the Chesapeake Bay watershed. These tadpoles were in a puddle by school. One turned yesterday and has lost his stub today. I ordered some pinhead crickets so he can try to eat tomorrow... and I'm getting rid of the gravel. Any other advice would be greatly appreciated! (I kept 5 tadpoles and the 1 frog... the rest returned to the aforementioned puddle.)

[science7]

Maybe some better photos would help? Someone told me they are bullfrogs... does this look right to you?

[PacMan1]

I dont believe those are bull frogs but maybe if i were to say id call them some sort of tree frog look up frogs found in virginia and see if u can identify those little dudes

[science7]

Thanks! I think I've narrowed it down to 7 possibilities. Haha. Pinewoods tree frog would make sense based on where I live. And he stays on the top of the wall most of the time.

[bugmankeith]

Could they be toads?

[herpdoc]

they're most likely toads since the tadpoles were jet black, seemed to have more medially placed eyes