I'd move it further away than your front yard if possible, they can be pretty good at finding their way 'home'.

I once did battle with a big American Toad in a huge wood pile that I was in the process of splitting and stacking. Pieces of wood would often do some tumbling- it wasn't a safe toad location. I moved the toad a few times to the safety of the garden, it would return to it's favorite wood pile even with several hundred feet of displacement. I eventually settled on being as careful as possible. Yours will hopefully not be as determined.

Best of luck and thanks for caring about the toads safety.