I bought Fire belly toads from Mitch also. I was similarly disappointed. I did not pay a premium price though. Mine were supposed to be bright green. They are all brown. He told me they were an inch, but they were a half inch when I got them. One ate but never grew, the rest have been healthy.

I really wanted to buy captive bred, and overall I'm happy and love my frogs. I do feel I was misled. I would advise caution with this seller, Rocky mountain frogs.