New Mexican Spadefoot Toad

[veebee723]

I recently caught two wild toads that were out near my home calling out for females. I filled the terrarium with lots of dirt to burrow, rocks, water, plants and limbs to shelter in. It appears as though only one is coming out at night to eat and hang out with us. We are not sure if we are seeing the same one or if they're taking turns...? We are wondering if we should try and dig up the other one or just figure maybe he's hibernating or (gasp) is dead. If so how is the safest way to do that? Any help is much appreciated. We live in Northern New Mexico.