The guy got immediately defensive when we sent him the pictures of the frogs. I told him that these were my FIRST and ONLY Red-Eyed Tree Frogs. It wasn't like I was asking for a full refund of all 3 Red-Eyed Tree Frogs and the Malaysian, I just wanted my LAG (which, as previously stated I DID get.) However, when he sent it he responded with "Your refund has been sent to your pay pal account, enjoy the <amount>, my friend"

Since he was so set on saying that the frogs were PERFECT when he sent them, I examined the packaging more carefully. Of the 3 RETFs that he sent, 2 were visible when I opened the box, the other was not. The one that was not visible only had the nose rub, while the other 2 had scratches all over their heads. So, I looked at the lids:







You can see where he made air holes and simply left them sharp! 2 of the 3 Red-Eyed Tree Frogs had access to these holes for no telling how long while in transit.

My husband plans to write him again today and show him the pictures of the lids. Of course, I am sure that he will say these weren't his lids. After he said that these were not the frogs that he sent me, I sent him the picture (previously posted) of the box as I opened it. That's when he wrote back the one line of "enjoy the <amount>, my friend". He could CLEARLY see all of his packaging and the frogs that were his. My husband even told him to check the EXIF data on my pictures, which clearly were for yesterday. Luckily, my husband does a lot of dealing in Tarantulas, so I clearly document ALL package openings just in case of the unfortunate DOA.

As far as his comment of "Don't respond to any of my ads because you won't be getting any more animals from me", I do not WANT more animals from him. I was never trying to get the 2 living frogs replaced and I will love them the same, scratches or not!