My frog hates the vitamin (HerpVite) and calcium dusts that I initially purchased. I have had some success with a spray (Zilla) but noticed that it doesn't contain vitamin D3. I can also inject food items with calcium solution, but again there's no D3. I'd really like to correctly supplement his food.

I've seen a few replies where people have better luck getting their frog to take the Repashy supplement. My question is: should I be wary because it's an all-in-one supplement? I read up on the product website, and the manufacturer states that nowadays an all-in-one supplement won't have the shortened shelf life of earlier products. I think I've also seen another all-in-one, made by ZooMed, so he's not alone in believing that. Of course, these are all statements made by the manufacturers of said products; then again, Mr. Repashy's products have a good reputation in the fish and shrimp communities (and possibly others).

What's the consensus these days?