Painted Mantella

[MantellaGuy]

Like I said on Facebook a short while ago, this does resemble Mantella madgascarensis. However, I think this may actually be a hybrid specimen, especially considering this is more than likely a WC individual anyway.

This could well be a Mantella pulchra x madagascarensis/baroni hybrid in my opinion... It is entirely possible and new colourations and confer species are found all the time out in Madagascar.

Without DNA and genetic testing, I don't think you'll know for sure! But I can definitely say that this is crtainly and most definitely not, Mantella pulchra (pictured below). It doesn't share any of the same colourations, especially on the front of the snout which your individual has markings on, except for the limbs that have a slight colouration.



I would be very dubious about putting this with other individuals, if this is indeed a hybrid specimen which it could be completely possible, then it could muck up potential bloodlines.

[Pirarucu]

Like I said on Facebook a short while ago, this does resemble Mantella madgascarensis. However, I think this may actually be a hybrid specimen, especially considering this is more than likely a WC individual anyway.

This could well be a Mantella pulchra x madagascarensis/baroni hybrid in my opinion... It is entirely possible and new colourations and confer species are found all the time out in Madagascar.

Without DNA and genetic testing, I don't think you'll know for sure! But I can definitely say that this is crtainly and most definitely not, Mantella pulchra (pictured below). It doesn't share any of the same colourations, especially on the front of the snout which your individual has markings on, except for the limbs that have a slight colouration.



I would be very dubious about putting this with other individuals, if this is indeed a hybrid specimen which it could be completely possible, then it could muck up potential bloodlines.

I asked whether it may be a hybrid on Facebook, but the point was largely ignored so I dropped it. Only problem is, so far as I'm aware M. pulchra is only sympatric with M. baroni, not M. madagascariensis. As this specimen shows no signs of being a baroni, if it is a hybrid it would be between pulchra and madagascariensis. Therefore it is either CBB and a hybrid or WC and a madagascariensis.

[MantellaGuy]

I asked whether it may be a hybrid on Facebook, but the point was largely ignored so I dropped it. Only problem is, so far as I'm aware M. pulchra is only sympatric with M. baroni, not M. madagascariensis. As this specimen shows no signs of being a baroni, if it is a hybrid it would be between pulchra and madagascariensis. Therefore it is either CBB and a hybrid or WC and a madagascariensis.

I thought I said something about it? I did edit my comment through my ipad Facebook :/ in all honesty, this individual would have been WC due to the size of it, unless the chap you purchased from had kept a good few years. Unless it is coming into its colours (which I highly doubt due to the odd colouration at this size), this more than likely cam from the latest import from Madagascar which took place approximately 2-3 months ago now. Now being a hybrid is entirely possible, I actually would put it right at the top of the list in all honesty, because all Mantella are more than capable to hybridise... You can see some really odd ones about aswell.
But in all honesty, you will never be able to find out unless you invested a bit of money into genetic identification, would be interesting to find out though!

[Pirarucu]

I thought I said something about it? I did edit my comment through my ipad Facebook :/ in all honesty, this individual would have been WC due to the size of it, unless the chap you purchased from had kept a good few years. Unless it is coming into its colours (which I highly doubt due to the odd colouration at this size), this more than likely cam from the latest import from Madagascar which took place approximately 2-3 months ago now. Now being a hybrid is entirely possible, I actually would put it right at the top of the list in all honesty, because all Mantella are more than capable to hybridise... You can see some really odd ones about aswell.
But in all honesty, you will never be able to find out unless you invested a bit of money into genetic identification, would be interesting to find out though!

I never saw it. What group was it in? It didn't come in with the last shipment, they got her in with a bunch of dart frogs about six months ago. I agree that it's very possible that Mantellas can hybridize, my point is that if it is WC then it cannot be a pulchra/madagascariensis cross because they do not share habitat.

[MantellaGuy]

I never saw it. What group was it in? It didn't come in with the last shipment, they got her in with a bunch of dart frogs about six months ago. I agree that it's very possible that Mantellas can hybridize, my point is that if it is WC then it cannot be a pulchra/madagascariensis cross because they do not share habitat.

Think it was IMS. And there was also a shipment at around about October time, like there is every year so knowing that it was at 6 months at least that they found the individual, then it is still likely... I know this because the imports are normally advertised around Late August to September and then again in late December to January...
Mantella species can hybridise, it isn't just a simple possibility lol but the whole point I am raising towards it being imported is, like with most exported individuals from Madagascar, they are kept mainly together, with different species so there wouldn't be simple Mantella aurantiaca groups or Mantella madagascarensis groups, and the gathering of individuals is done well in advance of the importation shipment departure. This could be a few months in advance...
Yes their distribution range doesn't concede with the two species, I know full well the distribution of all the genus, but after stating how imports are built up, I have explained my point a little better for you.

There are, like I stated before, many confer species found within the distribution ranges of all the species, so it could also be a Confer individual... But like I said, you will never know what the individual will be, unless, have you asked for more information from the original seller?

EDIT - Infact it could well be a Confer specimen, like you would find with various specimens of M.crocea etc. I did find a photo that matched your individual somewhere on the web. I'll try and find it for you.

[Pirarucu]

Think it was IMS. And there was also a shipment then at around about October time, like there is every year so knowing that it was at 6 months at least that they found the individual, then it is still likely...
Mantella species can hybridise, it isn't just a simple possibility lol but the whole point I am raising towards it being imported is, like with most exported individuals from Madagascar, they are kept mainly together, with different species so there wouldn't be simple Mantella aurantiaca groups or Mantella madagascarensis groups, and the gathering of individuals is done well in advance of the importation shipment departure...
Yes their distribution range doesn't concede with the two species, I know full well the distribution of all the genus, but after stating how imports are built up, I have explained my point a little better for you.

There are, like I stated before, many confer species found within the distribution ranges of all the species, so it could also be a Confer individual... But like I said, you will never know what the individual will be, unless, have you asked for more information from the original seller?

Still don't see it, maybe someone deleted it. That's a good point though, to clarify you're saying that she could have been produced while the different species were housed together awaiting departure? I am trying to find the original seller currently. The place I bought it from didn't know much, since they didn't even know that they had her.
Also to clarify, what do you mean when you refer to "confer" species?

[MantellaGuy]

Still don't see it, maybe someone deleted it. That's a good point though, to clarify you're saying that she could have been produced while the different species were housed together awaiting departure? I am trying to find the original seller currently. The place I bought it from didn't know much, since they didn't even know that they had her.
Also to clarify, what do you mean when you refer to "confer" species?

Bugger, for that I am apologetic! We'll least you got to see my full response now and certainly, this is a high possibility in all honesty that could end up with various hybridise specimens being hatched out and surviving! Lol they could be housed for a great length of time before being departed in the import, your talking months...

And well ell I think the best bet is finding the details out about where they got the D.leucomelas in all honesty.... Find their supplier and you will find out more...

and, you will commonly see a species having 'cf.' in the middle of their scientific naming which will look like Mantella.cf.madagascarensis. This basically means in Latin "consult" or you can interpret that as "compare", which normally means in regards to animal species, comparing two or more of the same species with a single irregular specimen which clearly isn't one or the other, but shows certain traits...
You will see some unusual specimens of Mantella on your travels on the internet and if you look at the Conservation. international Pocket Guide of Mantella species, you will see a lot of oddly coloured M.milotympanum or M.crocea, these would be labeled or considered a confer species.