I've never used the honey treatment as I've never had to (knock on wood), so can't give my two cents on that unfortunately. As far as the Neosporin, I was always taught not to buy any with the pain reliever in it as it could have harmful effects on the reptiles, as far as with amphibians I don't know.

This is what's included in my kit, it was compiled based on Melissa Kaplan's recommendations on Anapsid.org:

Betadine (Povidone Iodine solution)
Nolvassan (chlorhexadine diacetate) or Hibiclens (chlorhexadine gluconate) - disinfectant
Assorted needles
Assorted syringes
Eye Dropper
Bead containers (fecal jars)
Kwik Stop (Styptic Powder - stops bleeding)
Claw Clippers
Pill cutter/crusher
KY Jelly (without spermicide)
Paper first aid tape (goes against reptile skin and releases without damaging the scales)
Adhesive first aid tape (goes on top of the paper tape)
Mineral Oil (Lubricant)
Q-Tips
Gauze Sponges
Photo Loupe (used for looking at negatives, works great for looking at reptile skin after shed)
Stethoscope
Terry Towels
Calcium gluconate
Calcium glubionate
Diorlyte (the UK's version of Pedialyte)
Reptile Critical Care formula
Sterlie saline
Germolene (antibiotic ointment)
Silvadene cream (burn treatment)
Fenbendazole (Panacur)
Metronidazole (Flagyl)
Enrofloxacin (Baytril)
10lbs Food Scale
and Tylenol - For me... haha