Any update on your frogs?
![United States [United States]](images/flags/United States.gif)
Any update on your frogs?
72 Gallon Bow - ACF and GF tank.
26 Gallon Bow - ACF tank.
20 Gallon Long - ACF tank.
"If there were an invisible cat in that chair, the chair would look empty. But the chair does look empty; therefore there is an invisible cat in it." C.S. Lewis, Four Loves, 1958
Hello,
I had computer problems, then I could not come on the forum. To treat my frogs, I wonder if I can quarantine in a 20 liter aquarium for their salt baths. Is it enough if I put 20 liters my frogs one after another (not all at once) to treat? Now, I removed my Corydoras. I feed them every two days, varying with Daphnia or Artemia nutrient jelly, small cooked shrimp and earthworms. I have a pump 1000 liters, and I change 50% water every two weeks.
Thank you very much.
9 Frogs is a ton in what is roughly a 42 gallon aquarium. What shape is it? Hex? I would remove the kuhlis too. They look like works. I am surprised they are not already eaten. I can't offer much advice on top of what was given. I am curious if you feed the daphnia frozen or thawed though. I can't see how they would get enough if thawed because it is so tiny and goes everywhere. I would avoid the cooked shrimp too. You should be feeding raw.
![United States [United States]](images/flags/United States.gif)
I would recommend Reptomin (found in the reptile aisle) and earthworms only and would not feed the rest.
As far as salt baths, the 20L is fine for them. Use clean water, dechlorinate it, for every gallon of water in the bath tank use 1/2 tsp of epsom salt. Each frog needs to sit for up to an hour and each frog needs it's own bath water - don't reuse between frogs.
Repeat once daily.
I am a little concerned as it has been 2 and 1/2 months since you originally posted regarding their bloat. Can you post some updated pictures/videos of their condition?
72 Gallon Bow - ACF and GF tank.
26 Gallon Bow - ACF tank.
20 Gallon Long - ACF tank.
"If there were an invisible cat in that chair, the chair would look empty. But the chair does look empty; therefore there is an invisible cat in it." C.S. Lewis, Four Loves, 1958
I give them Daphnias nutritious jelly. I can not remove the Khulis, because I have no other aquarium where they would be happy. For salt baths, I am afraid to disturb the frogs in bathing them many times. They will not like change many times in different aquarium.
Here are pictures of my bloated frogs currently :
Those frogs look horrible. I think you need to be willing to do what is necessary. Give them their own tank, reduce your numbers or increase tank size, get them on some good food, treat them as perscribed.
![United States [United States]](images/flags/United States.gif)
Not doing anything is much more cruel then making them a bit annoyed at giving them salt baths that may save them. At this point, if you do nothing then they will eventually die.
Leaving your tank the way it is is not a suitable environment for any of it's inhabitants. They kuhlis will eventually end up being eaten...and the frogs will most likely eventually die.
Again, I must insist/beg if you will, that you do something to help these poor frogs. They are truly suffering.
72 Gallon Bow - ACF and GF tank.
26 Gallon Bow - ACF tank.
20 Gallon Long - ACF tank.
"If there were an invisible cat in that chair, the chair would look empty. But the chair does look empty; therefore there is an invisible cat in it." C.S. Lewis, Four Loves, 1958
On a French forum, someone told me that salt baths are unnecessary. I quote the message:
"From my points of view, the frog are Being obese with too much chicken and beef and fiber fats Epsom salt .. Will only help a little for Them to Increase Their excreting system, Because your frogs are not exothalmia Suffering Whereas gold has provided the body fluids hAS excesive. In your case, the one Caused That is bloated symtomps obesitas, provided based on a diet Where the fiber and fats are digested and Already Became hand of the body ..
So, I do not think epsom salt is nessesary for this condition, Just Give hum a diet based on what Variety Laurent/tyrano34/webmaster Stated in the previous post ... In general, I only know that Epsom Salt (MgSO4·7H2O) is usually used as a laxative medicine or saline laxative, which means that epsom salt helps water creatures to excrete their waste part. Water creature depends highly on minerals for them to excrete as in like osmotic regulation system. So, be it their "sweat" and/or "Digestive system", epsom salt helps "smoother" their digestive system.
Try to read about epsom salt:
Magnesium sulfate - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Hypomagnesemia - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Just like in human, there's no really cure for obesity unless you choose the right diet and have some work out. Well, that's about the same with animals.. Just make them active and burned out that saturated fats with less meaty diet of course..
In my opinion, usually a bloated body is diagnosed as exothalmia and epsom salt will work to "smoother" their skin so the fluid will come out easier. But in this case as stated that the Xenopus' owner had been feeding them with chicken and beef which not all animals with more primitive digesting system than human could really digest chicken and beef because of the protein, fat, and fiber in chicken and beef somewhat different from protein we could get from insects which the animals usually eat... "
![United States [United States]](images/flags/United States.gif)
These are not just fat frogs - it is not that they are packing on the pounds and sitting around watching a lot of cable TV.
These frogs have a disease. In my opinion, you have been posting around elsewhere hoping someone would give you an answer you liked, rather than the answers you need.
I feel quite strongly, and I think other members would also, that if these were my frogs, I wouldn't hesitate to try any solution given to me...even on the chance that it MIGHT help. I would be trying to help them as fast as I was capable.
Considering you originally posted this 3 full months ago when the frogs were already very bloated which means they have been bloated from a considerable time before your original post, I do not have a lot of faith for their outcome.
Epson salt baths are extremely easy to do and have been very successful in treating many frogs on this forum including one of my own.
72 Gallon Bow - ACF and GF tank.
26 Gallon Bow - ACF tank.
20 Gallon Long - ACF tank.
"If there were an invisible cat in that chair, the chair would look empty. But the chair does look empty; therefore there is an invisible cat in it." C.S. Lewis, Four Loves, 1958
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)